A small white fishing skiff tied to a short timber landing beside calm lagoon water and a distant mangrove shoreline.

Sebastian Voted to Buy the Dock Next to Fisherman's Landing. What Changes on Indian River Drive?

November 12, 2026

The Sembler property at 1527 and 1528 Indian River Drive runs from U.S. 1 to the Indian River Lagoon. Its large pier and dock structure sit right beside Fisherman's Landing, the city's existing working waterfront. The Sembler family name has been attached to the property for a long time. At its Monday, Nov. 2 meeting, the Sebastian City Council voted to buy it.

The vote shows where Sebastian is putting its money on the river. The city is paying to keep Indian River Drive a place where fish and oysters come ashore. The building that once put that catch in front of residents, the old Crab-E-Bill's fish market, has been empty since 2024 and is still waiting on a replacement.

The Price Was Above Appraisal, and the Vote Was Unanimous

Sebastian Daily reported that council approved a $2.5 million purchase and sale agreement for the roughly 1.3-acre parcel and its docks. The vote also authorized City Manager Brian Benton and the city attorney to close the deal. Two recent appraisals averaged about $2.1 million. Under the city charter, paying more than that average required a supermajority. The motion passed 5-0.

The $2.5 million figure has a history. The property was listed at $2.9 million in the summer of 2022, when council first debated buying it, according to Hometown News. In early 2023 the city offered $1.2 million and then unanimously turned down a $2.5 million counteroffer. Earlier this year, council approved a Florida Communities Trust grant agreement that assumed a lower total. Negotiations still ended at $2.5 million, the same number council rejected three years earlier.

Council said yes this time because of how the deal is funded:

Source Amount
Proceeds from the sale of the old public works compound About $990,000
Community Redevelopment Agency money budgeted as a grant match $250,000
General fund reserves, to cover the full amount at closing About $1.26 million
Florida Communities Trust grant, reimbursed after closing $1.041 million
Additional reimbursable grant $250,000

Benton told council that once the reimbursements arrive, the net effect on general fund reserves should be minimal. Council Member Christopher Nunn called the funding package a "no-brainer," given how little unrestricted city money is ultimately at risk. Closing is expected once the remaining paperwork is finished.

Who Ties Up at These Docks

Council described the purchase as a way to keep the site in commercial fishing and aquaculture rather than see it turn into residential development. Mayor Fred Jones said the goal is to preserve, and eventually expand, the working waterfront activity already happening beside Fisherman's Landing.

Two operations matter most here.

  • Fisherman's Landing Sebastian Inc. is a nonprofit that works to preserve the city's working waterfront and provides low-cost dockage for commercial fishing boats. It holds a 10-year lease on the city-owned Fisherman's Landing land. TCPalm reported in February that about 10 fishers land roughly 350,000 pounds of fish a year there.
  • Treasure Coast Shellfish is the current tenant on the Sembler property. Its operator, Nicolette Mariano, runs the only oyster farm in Indian River County. During public comment she told council that access to the dock has been essential to her business. TCPalm's profile of the farm says it harvests oysters from the lagoon south of Sebastian Inlet and packs them for market or wholesale orders.

According to TCPalm, adding the Sembler property and its docks would take Sebastian's working waterfront from 10 boats to 40. For comparison, the same report counted more than 100 fishers at the Port Salerno docks in Manatee Pocket, and about 80 offloading at Florida Fresh Fish in Fort Pierce. Sebastian's fleet is small next to those harbors, and this purchase gives it room to grow. City staff have said their first priority after closing is keeping the oyster operation in place, with public access and other amenities to be explored later.

The Building That Used to Sell the Catch

Fisherman's Landing's own building, the Hurricane Harbor structure at 1540 Indian River Drive, used to house Crab-E-Bill's fish market. Hometown News reported that the city declined to renew that lease in 2024, and the building has been vacant since.

The city plans to demolish it and build a new one. TCPalm reported in July 2025 that Sebastian would use a $100,000 Florida Inland Navigation District grant, matched by $100,000 from its Community Redevelopment Agency, to design and engineer the replacement. Around the same time, Sebastian Daily reported on the options the city had studied: rebuilding, partial restoration or extensive renovation, each estimated at about $2.5 million or more. The ideas for the site included community events, demonstrations and learning programs.

So the lagoon side of the street is set to grow from one dock operation to two. For now, the building that would let a passerby walk in and buy what those boats bring back exists only as a plan.

The Indian River Seafood Market website lists the store at 645 Sebastian Blvd., open Wednesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. and Saturday from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. The site says it sells fresh seafood cut to order, including mahi-mahi, grouper, pompano, snapper and local flounder. Small shops adjust their hours, so check the site before you go.

A Hard Week for Oysters

The case for a working oyster dock depends on the lagoon, and the lagoon had a rough start to November. On Nov. 6, Sebastian Daily reported predawn dissolved oxygen of 5.68 mg/L at the Sebastian station, above its 5.0 mg/L watch line. Salinity had fallen to 7.10 PSU from 27.52 on Nov. 2, a drop that stresses oysters, clams and seagrass.

By Nov. 8, the follow-up report had oxygen back up to 7.01 mg/L. Salinity was still 11.22 PSU, well below the 25 to 30 typical for that part of the lagoon, and shellfish were still under freshwater stress. Both reports described a watch, not a harvest closure. Both told harvesters to check the official shellfish-area status from the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services before going out.

A week like this shows why access to the dock matters to a farm like Treasure Coast Shellfish. Its oysters grow in the same water those readings measure.

The Ramp at Main Street

The Capt. Robert Hardee Main Street Boat Ramp, at Main Street and Indian River Drive, has also been closed this fall. The city closed it for dredging starting Oct. 19. Sebastian Daily reported on Oct. 22 that bad weather and a change in the dewatering process had pushed the closure through Saturday, Nov. 7. The Yacht Club Boat Ramp stayed open as the alternative. Before you trailer down to Main Street this weekend, check the City of Sebastian site for the ramp's current status.

Where Each Piece Stands

For the riverfront between Main Street and the Sembler pier, here is the order of events so far:

  1. Summer 2022: Council debates buying the Sembler property, then listed at $2.9 million.
  2. Early 2023: The city offers $1.2 million and turns down a $2.5 million counteroffer.
  3. 2024: The city does not renew the fish market lease at Hurricane Harbor, and the building goes vacant.
  4. July 2025: FIND and CRA money is set aside to design a replacement building.
  5. Early 2026: Council approves the Florida Communities Trust grant agreement.
  6. Oct. 19 to Nov. 7, 2026: The Main Street ramp is closed for dredging.
  7. Nov. 2, 2026: Council votes 5-0 for the $2.5 million purchase, with closing to follow once documentation is complete.

The next public milestone is closing on the Sembler property. The replacement building at 1540 Indian River Drive is the piece that could bring a fish counter back to the riverfront.

If you live near Indian River Drive or own property along the river and want to talk through how these changes might affect your street, Krissy Lindbaek would be glad to hear from you. Let's Connect.

Follow Krissy on Social Media

Work With Krissy

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today to find out how I can be of assistance to you!